Mama Theresa's Pizzeria & Restaurant in East Meadow

Best pizza I've had in a long time, the pasta and bread were also very delicious, great service too.

I used the one in East Meadow, I had it catered and the food was great, everything was great. The people there were very nice and attentive and everything was on time. Will use them again.

My dad asked for blue cheese for my buffalo chicken roll and he gave me marinara instead. I'm calling the police.

Highly recommended.

Great food but not friendly staff

Mama Theresa's never disappoints. Food is always delicious. They have a wide variety of pizzas, salads and paninis. We dined in for lunch today for the first time (we usually order takeout or delivery) and was very impressed. The lunch menu is awesome! I highly recommend Mama Theresa's.

I have lunch here usually once a week, never had any problems with staff and food is always delicious. Thank you as always!

Consistently good food albeit expensive.

Pizza was good but unsanitary counter person. Handled pizza with same gloves as handling money.

I used to eat here all the time, but that authentic flavor no longer exists. I love their paninis and the Flatbread. There's something different about the pizza , although tasty but not mouth watering for me anymore.

Great tasting pizzas at Mama Theresa's! The pastas are decent but good enough to order again. I usually get a regular pie and a couple of pasta dishes. The Chicken Parmigiana is ok they give a decent sized portion of the chicken breast.the service and staff here are pretty good and the food comes out quick. They also have coupons in the local mail and circulars. Recommended if you're in the East Meadow area.

I love the food there is a very beatiful place!

The pizza is always fresh and they got great slices! Perfect place to go for lunch.

Great tasting food and customer service. There’s never a wait for this location. Chicken panini is a must try! Also recommend the garlic knots with marinara sauce!!!!

Just a little too expensive other than that it's great

Great Pizza and Pasta

Excellent as always. Staff all are excellent. Chicken Parmesan and fettucini Alfredo unbelievable scrumptious. Left overs for another meal. Prices are great. Cholera lava cake and cheese cake was fantastic.

Tried a regular cheese slice and I was very disappointed. It’s definitely not worth the money I had better pizza in other parts in Long Island for cheaper

Their food is absolutely horrible, I don't know about the people who brag about them, I tried more than one item and it was a total waste of money. Their chicken roll is as big as a hot dog bun, with uncooked chicken mixed with the most disgusting sauce i ever tasted. Not only the food is bad, it is over priced. If I can i wouldn't give them even One star

Food was great not just pizz

My family's favorite Pizza. I've been going there for years, almost every Thursday. Thank-you John and all the staff!

Food is great service is awesome as well not a long wait at all

The food is the delicious and the service is leisurely.

The food is great but the customer service is exceptional! These people really know how to treat their customers. Thank you Ashley C and the rest of the girls for such a great experience! You definitely have life long customers!

Very good food!

Great pizza and lasagne. Service was fast for lunch. Best marinated chicken panini around. I had eaten here many times..i guess you can tell.

Great buffalo pizza and prices. Nice atmosphere, not too tight depending on your time.

My best place for my family and me highly recommended to everyone

It was my fist visit at this location to have a quick bite with friends... It was nice enough-- The eggplant was very well made! I really like the cozy feel of the dining room. And the waitress?! Very warm and kind. Yes.., I'd go back again!

Ordered chicken parm hero today. Was disappointed. Chicken didnt taste fresh. The coating came right off. The chicken was very thin and on the tough side. You need to pound out the cutlet before frying it.

It was my first time here and I was pleasantly surprised by the delicious food and friendly service.

The food is pretty good not too expensive and the shrimp parm hero awesome.

High quality ingredients = high quality food. Always fresh and tasty. This place is popular so it's always crowded which can be annoying if you're in a hurry.

So I placed an order simple pie half pepperoni the other half cheese with two 1 litter sodas I live about 7min away the order was placed at 6:33pm I was told it would be at my door step in 45 they had me wait for 2hrs the worst and the teenager that answered the phone had the nerve to tell me next time call the other mama Theresa's my order was cold the Manager then got on the phone and said to me the credit card used to pay for the order will be canceled sheesh the least that could be done I get it its friday night but cold pizza nah not cool sorry not sorry used to like this place not so much anymore I wouldn't go back for nothing

Mama Theresa's never misses. The pizza and salads are so good I drive from Suffolk County to get it.

Food was great. I think it's a bit pricey, but it was delicious. Though, if you order a hero, be warned you have to make it yourself. Not sure if it's a delivery thing, but my chicken parm hero came separate. Had chicken in one container and a hero in wax paper.

Tried to support a local business during this pandemic and was completely disappointed with the service we were provided. We ordered a “ Family meal” from their menu provided on Uber eats , when the order came they only brought one out of the 4 items ordered. Understandably, mistakes happen but when we called to speak with the staff the owner wouldn’t even let us explain that we were missing items and said he never heard of this meal that was listed on our receipt from the restaurant . He wouldn’t even let us get a word in to explain the situation to him and just continued to raise his voice over the phone without apologizing at all for the mistake. I understand these are trying times which is why we try to continue to support local business but unfortunately this left a very sour taste in my mouth and we will not be ordering from them again.

Superbly served, ate royally and treated kindly! Mama mia that's a real pizza shop

You can expect quality pizza from this place everytime. The counter worker was a bit standoffish though.

It's good; a little pricey but the food is great.

Real Italian feel ,taste .

Heard about this restaurant from a co-worker. Needed them to bring seven pizzas to a party at noon. They arrived early with hot pies that were delicious and reasonably priced. Great job.

Nice atmosphere food nothing special

Food is always great. Not too much salt and delicious. The attitudes and prices could use some tweaking.

Love their pizza. The sauce tastes amazing. The cannoli comes in a pair sitting on cannoli filling with whip cream. The perfect end to a meal.

I’d like to point out I have never made a review before. I felt the need to make a Gmail account to point out there servers are horrible. Never go here 0 zeros

Such an amazingly great experience going to Mama Teresa's restaurant..... Excellent Italian food all made fresh with the great taste of Italy .....Superior service as you sit in wonderful extremely clean surroundings .... I went with family .... we ate .... we enjoyed...we left happy and will definitelyreturn to their dinning room for another fabulous meal .............

GOOD FOOD A LITTLE HIGHER PRICE BUT NOT ENOUGH FOOD ! 🤔😶

Called for delivery on a regular old Wednesday night...early. Told 20 min, after an hour we called to inquire where our food was, with no apology we were told it was on its way. When it finally arrived it was cold, considering it was an hour past when we were quoted it would delivered, no surprise, still no apology. Not asking for much here but sometimes an apology goes a long way. With a pizza place on every corner, don’t spend your money or your time here, move in to the next one.

Pretty limited pizza by the slice. My buffalo chicken slice crumbled after one bite so I had to use a knife and fork. I guess that means there was a ton of chicken there but I expect to eat a NY slice folded up and with one hand.